20% off SITEWIDE with code SPRING | Details

Filters

Category
  • Amish Fiction
  • Animal Books & Magazines
  • Best Selling Fiction Books
  • Blackberry Valley Mysteries
  • Book Sets
  • Christian Fiction Books
  • Cozy Mysteries
  • eBooks
  • Fiction eBooks
  • Gift Shop Mysteries
  • Holiday Fiction
  • Mysteries & Wonders of the Bible
  • Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm
  • Mysteries of Lancaster County
  • Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard
  • Mysteries of Silver Peak
  • Mystery Christian Fiction
  • New Release Christian Books
  • Patchwork Mysteries
  • Sale
  • Savannah Secrets
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic
  • Secrets of Mary's Bookshop
  • Secrets of the Blue Hill Library
  • Secrets of Wayfarers Inn
  • Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries
  • Tearoom Mysteries
  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries
Price

Mystery Christian Fiction

Category
  • Amish Fiction
  • Animal Books & Magazines
  • Best Selling Fiction Books
  • Blackberry Valley Mysteries
  • Book Sets
  • Christian Fiction Books
  • Cozy Mysteries
  • eBooks
  • Fiction eBooks
  • Gift Shop Mysteries
  • Holiday Fiction
  • Mysteries & Wonders of the Bible
  • Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm
  • Mysteries of Lancaster County
  • Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard
  • Mysteries of Silver Peak
  • Mystery Christian Fiction
  • New Release Christian Books
  • Patchwork Mysteries
  • Sale
  • Savannah Secrets
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic
  • Secrets of Mary's Bookshop
  • Secrets of the Blue Hill Library
  • Secrets of Wayfarers Inn
  • Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries
  • Tearoom Mysteries
  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries
Price
  • The Christmas Key Book Cover

    When Anne finds a mysterious key in Aunt Edie’s belongings, she discovers that it belongs to a cubby in the local church; inside the compartment is a beautiful sapphire ring! Is the ring Edie’s, and if so, why is the reverend acting suspiciously when Anne questions him about it? As she investigates, she realizes that there is a significant amount of her great-aunt’s history that is still shrouded in mystery. Meanwhile, can Anne and her family save the church’s Christmas production when plans go awry? Read to find out in this stirring exploit from the beautiful town of Blue Hill!

  • All Sewn Up Book Cover

    Anne has found receipts for two-dozen fancy sewing machines purchased by her great-aunt Edie, and none of them are a match for the model Aunt Edie used in her house. What happened to them, and why would Anne’s late relative buy so many machines? Meanwhile, Liddie embarks on a mission to collect clothing for needy children in Blue Hill. Join Anne, her family, and the residents of Blue Hill on a heartwarming adventure of charity, mystery, and community!

  • At Face Value

    Author: Ocieanna Fleiss

  • Empty Saddle Book Cover

    After Sadie’s granddaughter, Sara, goes missing and her horse returns with only three shoes, Sadie and the Silver Peak community must find her before she comes to any harm! Using her restless nights to investigate a few items she purchased for her store, Sadie wonders if she can ever properly focus while her granddaughter is missing. Will faith and a grandmother’s love be enough to solve this puzzling mystery, or has Sadie finally met her match?

  • Savannah Secrets - Seasons Meetings - Book 8-0

    Author: Anne Marie Rodgers

  • Another's Treasure - Mysteries of Lancaster County - Book 1

    Escape to Pennsylvania’s Amish Country where Antiques, Hidden Treasures, and Mountains of Mysteries Await You!

    Get 2 FREE GIFTS (a $30 value) just for trying these mysteries.

    Read a Free Preview Now!

  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic Book 7: Movers and Shakers-0

    In the heartwarming tale of loss and love, Tracy and Amy seek their missing grandmother’s salt-and-pepper shaker sets for a memorable Christmas. But when the shakers vanish, they unravel a hidden romance and suspect their estranged cousin, Leigh, while trying to mend broken bonds. Will uncovering the truth bring their cherished collection back together?

  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries Book 8: Mercy's Healing-0

    Sweet Carolina Mysteries, formerly known as Miracles & Mysteries of Mercy Hospital. Same content, thrilling stories and enigmatic mysteries. 

    Join hospital volunteer turned sleuth, Anne Mabry, on a thrilling ride of mystery, pranks, and hidden secrets. Can she and her allies stop the chaos in time? A gripping tale of courage and camaraderie!

  • Tea is for Treasure Book Cover

    When Elaine and Jan unexpectedly receive a beautiful white china teapot, they find a mysterious map and poem inside that supposedly lead to a hidden treasure! However, when Nigel Fox is injured and delivers a warning to the cousins, they begin to wonder if this profound encounter is related to the treasure. At the same time, Elaine and Jan put the clues together about the sapphire ring they found in the walls of their tearoom. What will this puzzle divulge about the ring? What stories will history have to tell?

  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries Book 8: Accentuate the Positive-0

    In a quaint corner of Whistle Stop Café, Janet Shaw’s vintage writing haven sparks tales of love, mystery, and camaraderie. Amid stolen pens and cherished memories, she discovers the true treasures of the heart.

  • If Walls Could Talk Book Cover

    While investigating the damage in the basement of the library after a storm, Anne and Alex discover a human skeleton buried with an arrowhead and Aunt Edie’s bow and arrow. Did Anne’s great-aunt play a role in the death of this mysterious figure? Meanwhile, Anne encourages Ben to participate in the local church’s father-son retreat, to Ben’s disquiet. Can she figure out a way to get Ben enthusiastic about the event with one of Aunt Edie’s beloved hobbies?

  • Mixed Signals - Mysteries of Lancaster County - Hardcover

    Author: Beth Adams

  • Moonlit Shadows

    Author: Becky Melby

  • Reunion Dance Book Cover

    When Sadie’s friend, Ann, comes to town in order to help plan their high school reunion, she arrives bearing some profound news: her DNA does not match that of her parents! Could a strange necklace hidden in Ann’s collar somehow be related to the old house that Sadie is restoring? Meanwhile, Sadie is forced to mediate between Ann and her best friend, Roz, as they debate over how to organize their high school reunion. Join Sadie on an unpredictable adventure about the value of friendship and a family’s love.

Popular products

Community Newsletter

Get More Inspiration Delivered to Your Inbox

Scroll to Top